For many owners, the sale of a business produces a large capital gain in a single year. Whether a gift is made before or after the sale affects the size of the deduction, the capital gains tax owed, and the options available for future giving. Working with a New York City estate planning lawyer early in the sale process allows charitable goals to be built into the transaction rather than added afterward. At Abelaj Law, PC, Jennifer V. Abelaj draws on her background as a Certified Public Accountant to help business owners evaluate both the legal and tax sides of these decisions.

Why the Timing of a Charitable Gift Matters

When an owner gives an interest in a business to a public charity or donor-advised fund before the sale, the owner may be able to deduct the fair market value of an interest held for more than one year, generally up to 30 percent of adjusted gross income. If the charity later sells the interest as part of the transaction, it generally owes no capital gains tax on that portion because it is tax-exempt. The charity should not be legally obligated to sell at the time of the gift, or the gain may be taxed back to the donor.

If the owner sells first and donates cash afterward, the full gain is taxed to the owner. The cash gift still produces a deduction, but the opportunity to avoid tax on the donated portion of the gain is lost.

Making a Gift Before the Sale Closes

A pre-sale gift can offer the greatest tax benefit, but it also carries the most technical risk. The following rules affect whether the gift works as intended.

The Assignment of Income Doctrine

Under the anticipatory assignment of income doctrine, if a sale is already a practical certainty when the gift is made, the donor may be taxed on the gain even though the charity receives the money.

In Estate of Hoensheid v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2023-34, the Tax Court applied this doctrine to a gift of company stock made to a donor-advised fund just days before closing. The court found the sale had progressed too far and was a foregone conclusion, so the donor was taxed on the gain from the donated shares. The court did not set a bright-line deadline, holding that the result depends on the facts of each case. Making the gift earlier in the process, before the terms of a sale are settled, generally reduces this risk.

Valuation and Appraisal Requirements

A gift of nonpublicly traded stock valued at more than $10,000 generally requires a qualified appraisal prepared by a qualified appraiser and an appraisal summary filed with the donor’s return. In Hoensheid, the court also denied the charitable deduction because the appraisal did not meet these requirements, and it rejected the argument that the donors had substantially complied.

Gifts to Private Foundations

A private foundation gives a family more control over its giving, but the tax rules are less favorable than for public charities. A deduction for a gift of closely held stock to a private foundation is generally limited to the donor’s cost basis rather than fair market value. Annual deduction limits are also lower. Gifts of appreciated property are generally deductible up to 20 percent of adjusted gross income, and cash gifts up to 30 percent.

Foundations are also subject to rules that can make holding a business interest difficult. Excess business holdings rules generally limit how much of a company a foundation and its insiders may own together. Self-dealing rules restrict most transactions between a foundation and its substantial donors or their family members. For these reasons, some owners give stock to a public charity or donor-advised fund before the sale, then make cash gifts to a family foundation after closing.

Giving After the Sale

After closing, the owner may hold significant cash and may have a higher income than usual for that year. Cash gifts to public charities are generally deductible up to 60 percent of adjusted gross income, and unused deductions may carry forward for up to five years.

Recent federal changes under the One Big Beautiful Big Act affect how much a gift saves. Beginning in 2026, itemizers may deduct charitable gifts only to the extent they exceed 0.5 percent of adjusted gross income, and the top-bracket limit caps the tax value of itemized deductions at 35%.

New York caps the state charitable deduction for taxpayers with adjusted gross income over $1 million, allowing only a portion of the federal deduction. Running the numbers before making a gift can help determine how much to give and when.

Vehicles for a Long-Term Philanthropic Strategy

The right structure depends on the owner’s income needs, desire for family involvement, and estate planning goals. Common options include:

  • Donor-advised funds, which provide an immediate deduction while grants are recommended over time
  • Charitable remainder trusts, which can provide an income stream for life or a term of years, up to 20 years, with the remaining assets passing to charity
  • Private foundations, which offer the most control and can involve family members in grantmaking
  • Charitable lead trusts, which pay charity first and can later transfer remaining assets to heirs
  • Bequests and beneficiary designations, which pass assets to charity at death

Because a charitable remainder trust itself is generally exempt from income tax, it can usually sell contributed stock without paying immediate capital gains tax, although the assignment of income rules still apply to the timing of the transfer. A charitable remainder trust generally cannot hold S corporation stock, so the type of entity being sold affects which options are available.

Connecting Philanthropy to Your Estate Plan

Charitable gifts tied to a business sale also affect the owner’s estate plan. A large gift may reduce a future taxable estate, and charitable bequests are generally deductible for federal and New York estate tax purposes. Gifts to charity also reduce what passes to family members, so the plan should reflect how the owner wants to divide assets between the two.

Because the gift, the appraisal, and the sale documents need to be consistent, the owner’s attorney, CPA, and financial advisor should share information throughout the transaction. As both an attorney and a CPA, Jennifer Abelaj can review how a charitable structure affects income tax and estate tax together.

Plan Your Charitable Strategy Before the Sale

Charitable gifts of business interests are easiest to plan before a buyer signs a purchase agreement. Abelaj Law works with NYC business owners to coordinate charitable giving with their estate plans. To discuss charitable giving before or after a sale, call 212-328-9568 or send us a message online.